From Politics to Paranoia: The Far-Right and Ken Paxton's Impeachment Trial
Texas Scorecard is laying the groundwork for a conspiracy theory that they can promote within their echo chamber as the trial progresses into its second week.
![From Politics to Paranoia: The Far-Right and Ken Paxton's Impeachment Trial](/content/images/size/w2000/2023/09/uTPXDbmBPFTupYucover.jpg)
Throughout this article, we aim to provide readers with a comprehensive understanding of the multifaceted dynamics surrounding Ken Paxton's impeachment trial, highlighting the nuances, contradictions, and intriguing connections that have emerged.
Surrogates of The Enterprise announced plans for "the grassroots" to protest in Austin against the Paxton Impeachment
In the lead-up to the impeachment proceedings, The Enterprise and their spokespersons issued warnings to Texas Senate members, indicating that there would be repercussions if they voted against The Enterprise's interests.
Julie McCarty and Fran Rhodes made an appearance on Steve Bannon's show, where they stated the following:
- They are organizing a gathering in Austin.
- They will actively oppose Senators if they move forward with impeachment.
- On the fifth, they are bringing people to Austin, with caravans converging from all corners of the state.
Stickland Adopts The Enterprise's Playbook in Ken Paxton's Impeachment Defense, Mirroring Their Tactics in Bryan Slaton's Case
The initial report from Scorecard Confessions laid bare The Enterprise's playbook, originally designed to shield Bryan Slaton from expulsion. It appears that this very playbook has now been extended to Ken Paxton's defense:
Statements issued by RPT Legislative Priorities Chair Jill Glover and RPT Chair Matt Rinaldi alluded to the same strategic approach.
Here's a breakdown of the playbook's steps:
Step 1: Uncover evidence supporting alleged affairs involving two other members.
Step 2: Share this information with sympathetic media outlets to expose the alleged misconduct.
Step 3: Demand investigations or expulsions of those implicated, by drawing parallels between their actions and Representative Slaton's involvement with a teenager.
Step 4: If the House fails to expel Slaton, accuse the Speaker of hypocrisy, asserting that Slaton was only expelled because he was one of the few "true conservatives" in the legislature.
Like clockwork, Jonathan Stickland has followed The Enterprise's playbook to the letter throughout Ken Paxton's impeachment trial.
![](https://www.texasscorecard.co/content/images/2023/09/uTPXDbmBPFTupYu00001.png)
![](https://www.texasscorecard.co/content/images/2023/09/uTPXDbmBPFTupYu00005.png)
Daily Attendance Summary at the Paxton Impeachment Trial
Here is a summary of the attendance reported for each day of the Paxton Impeachment Trial:
Day 1 Attendance, as reported by Current Revolt:
30 min until start. Anemic attendance. Maybe next week they can pay people $50 to show up instead of tweet. pic.twitter.com/MAyu1a2Mpv
— Current Revolt (Tony O.) (@CurrentRevolt) September 5, 2023
Current Revolt was also told that a "bus full" of Paxton supporters was en route to Austin, but never appeared:
Related to the anemic attendance, we were told multiple times that a “bus full” of pro-Paxton supporters were going to show up in the afternoon. They never appeared.
Day 2 attendance, as reported by Eva Ruth Moravec:
Zero people in the line for public passes as staff begin to hand them out on Day 2 of Ken Paxton’s impeachment trial.
— Eva Ruth Moravec (@EvaRuth) September 6, 2023
Press line, on the other hand, is long. pic.twitter.com/NeGZZcXMCI
Day 3 attendance, as reported by The Texan:
Good morning from the Texas Senate’s court of impeachment. Senators are due at 9:00 a.m. to begin day 3 of @KenPaxtonTX’s impeachment trial. Paxton faces removal from office if any charge is sustained. #txlege @TheTexanNews pic.twitter.com/JkWP3HLkGJ
— Hayden Sparks (@HaydenJSparks) September 7, 2023
Day 4 attendance, as reported by The Texan:
.@TheTexanNews is at the Texas Capitol for day 4 of testimony in the impeachment trial of @KenPaxtonTX. When day 3 ended, Ryan Vassar, a former @TXAG employee who accused Paxton of misconduct, was being cross-examined. Paxton faces removal from office. #txlege @TheTexanNews pic.twitter.com/kFM6YLDWjX
— Hayden Sparks (@HaydenJSparks) September 8, 2023
It appears that the support for Ken Paxton during the trial has been described as anemic, with some suggesting that most of the attendees may have affiliations with The Enterprise.
Scorecard Alters Their Narrative Regarding Ken Paxton's Impeachment
The Texas Scorecard's Axis of Allies appears to be diligently attempting to formulate a conspiracy theory that is both credible and convincing, though they have yet to settle on one that meets these criteria. Below, you'll find some of the theories they're presently delving into.
The Bush's Involvement
During the initial day of Ken Paxton's Impeachment Trial, Texas Scorecard's Axis of Allies seized moments from Jeff Mateer's cross-examination by Tony Buzbee to assert that Deputy Attorney General's actions in reporting to the FBI were orchestrated by "The Bush's."
The Bush’s and fellow globalists are the ones going after our conservative AG @KenPaxtonTX
— Jonathan Stickland (@RepStickland) September 7, 2023
They hate him because he’s put America First, and exposes the RINOs.
They must be stopped.#TexasCorruption #PoliticalImpeachment#FreeKenPaxton#txlege https://t.co/Rqezn7buBb
So a lawyer deeply connected with the George W. Bush wing of the #GOP has been representing ALL of the conspirators in the @TXAG coup against @KenPaxton... And he hasn't been billing them? Who has been paying Johnny Sutton, I wonder? pic.twitter.com/BhFUTfwizn
— Michael Quinn Sullivan 🇺🇸 (@MQSullivan) September 8, 2023
TLR Becomes the New Explanation
Following Jeff Mateer's sworn testimony, where he affirmed that he had never spoken to George P. Bush (source), Tony Buzbee found himself in need of a fresh explanation and subsequently shifted the blame onto TLR.
Paxton's lawyer Tony Buzbee bringing up texts that former Paxton top aide Jeff Mateer, received from Dick Trabulsi, chair of Texans for Lawsuit Reform, after he resigned.
— Taylor Goldenstein (@taygoldenstein) September 6, 2023
Buzbee seems to be trying to further the theory that Paxton's adversaries at TLR are behind the impeachment.
Put the following on the stand:
— Jonathan Stickland (@RepStickland) September 6, 2023
Jordan Berry (Political consultant)
Dick Weekley (TLR)
Dick Trabulsi (TLR)
Daniel Hodge (Lobbyist)
Texans for Lawsuit Reform has hated @KenPaxtonTX for years, they spent millions trying to destroy him. They want nothing more than to see him gone.… https://t.co/B7fEnISXfx
Austin attorney Adam Loewy, as noted, expressed the view that the theory attributing the Paxton impeachment to TLR is more rooted in the longstanding animosity between Paxton's legal team and the organization rather than being based on a credible and plausible explanation.
I analyzed this goofy TLR (@lawsuitreform) theory that @KenPaxtonTX attorneys are pushing in this trial in the @HoustonChron #txlege pic.twitter.com/deHdwui6UV
— Adam Loewy (@LoewyLawFirm) September 8, 2023
Governor Abbott
Yesterday, Paxton's defense team brought @GovAbbott into the mix.
— Lauren McGaughy 🌟 (@lmcgaughy) September 7, 2023
They claimed the AG's senior staff tried to oust him in a coup, and went to the governor's staff and @lawsuitreform for help doing that.
Here's what Abbott's spox said in response:https://t.co/bO6Xg4b5Zw #txlege pic.twitter.com/CfY4eFgs3h
When the #PaxtonImpeachment trial starts up today, I’m interested in learning what role Luis Saenz, @GregAbbott_TX’s chief of staff, had in this whole mess.
— Michael Quinn Sullivan 🇺🇸 (@MQSullivan) September 7, 2023
His name has come up as the person @TXAG coup co-conspirators met with about what are now known to be innuendo and…
The Enterprise declares victory prior to Ranger Maxwell's testimony
This impeachment trial is over. The facts are clear and the Texas Senate will vote to dismiss the charges or acquit @KenPaxtonTX .
— Cary Cheshire (@CaryCheshireTX) September 7, 2023
The only question is how much longer the Republican majority is going to allow this expensive song and dance to continue. #txlege
What happened to pressuring Senators?
There seems to have been a noticeable shift in strategy by Texas Scorecard's Axis of Allies during Ken Paxton's impeachment trial. Initially, their strategy appeared to involve jury tampering of Senators and encouraging "the grassroots" support, which apparently did not yield significant results. However, they have now shifted their approach to proclaiming victory, even before Ranger David Maxwell's testimony, who was seen as credible.
Maxwell: I told Ken Paxton that Nate Paul's Ponzi Scheme would "rival Billie Sol Estes," the infamous Texas conman who was convicted of stealing millions of dollars from a federal crop subsidy program in the 1960s. #PaxtonTrial
— Robert Downen (@RobertDownen_) September 8, 2023
Austin Attorney Adam Loewy highlighted an interesting dynamic during the trial, where Paxton's defense spent considerable time praising Ranger Maxwell, acknowledging his legendary status. However, Paxton's lawyer Dan Cogdell then attempted, albeit unsuccessfully, to cast doubt on Maxwell's integrity.
Austin Attorney Rick Cofer's observations emphasize the significance of Ranger David Maxwell's testimony during Ken Paxton's impeachment trial, noting that Maxwell 'owned every decision that he made in this process,' and 'Jurors, whether they're Texas Senators or regular Texans, tend to place a great deal of credibility on the testimony of law enforcement witnesses. These are witnesses who generally don't have any reason to lie in the eyes of jurors... and (Maxwell) was the most effective witness for the prosecution all week."
In a similar vein, numerous influential conservatives voiced their support for Ranger Maxwell once his testimony had concluded, with Congressman Chip Roy among them.
I stand squarely alongside David Maxwell & those standing with him. He is a Texas Ranger, law enforcement veteran over 4 decades, & my friend. His integrity is rock solid against political hot air. #TxLege
— Chip Roy (@chiproytx) September 8, 2023
The Enterprise mouthpieces promptly labeled Roy as a "RINO" (Republican In Name Only).
Someone is going to call @chiproytx a RINO aren't they? https://t.co/5Q2BbHUZLy
— Chad Hasty (@ChadHastyRadio) September 8, 2023
This is stupid.
— Jeff Younger (@JeffYoungerShow) September 8, 2023
The Texas Ranger refused to investigate crimes committed by federal law enforcement in Texas against Texans.
That’s not integrity, it’s cowardice.
I guess @RepChipRoy is just another Deep State asshat. https://t.co/s2HQBSjECV
Former Senator Konni Burton and others within Texas GOP circles expressed their disapproval of the attacks on Roy.
Thank you for this @chiproytx. It's absolutely disgusting what conservative grassroots Texans are calling these honorable men who have fought *for them* unflinchingly. I'm so disgusted with each of them and the group that is spearheading this disgusting campaign of lies against… https://t.co/h7GjXidz2n
— Konni Burton (@KonniBurton) September 8, 2023
Paxton's claim that nothing but liberals and RINOs are behind the impeachment isn't looking too good at the moment https://t.co/hYbQiA4JoE
— David R. Brockman (@drdrbrockman.bsky.social) 🇺🇦 (@drdrbrockman) September 8, 2023
Wow. This on top of Gohmert coming out in support of the witnesses is huge. People need to let the process play out https://t.co/OmnW5Vqqqb
— Nuance Bro (@NuanceBro) September 9, 2023
TX Ranger David Maxwell gave the most powerful and sincere testimony today as a witness in the trial to impeach AG Ken Paxton. His no-nonsense and unshakeable composure, and his undeniable expertise while delivering the truth, closed out the week by giving Texans a strong sense… https://t.co/vDPPMTWDUE
— Cody Harris (@CodyforTexas) September 8, 2023
There are people replying and calling him a RINO.
— Derek Ryan (@longhornderek) September 8, 2023
September 8, 2023. The official day the term “RINO” died. It no longer has any meaning whatsoever. #txlege https://t.co/0D8ZNF1nxC
Chip is a conservative’s conservative. He never wavers on principles or values. And, I agree 1000% with him on this. #txlege https://t.co/fqmEINR1nL
— Chad Wilbanks (@ChadWilbanks) September 8, 2023
The Enterprise readies a new conspiracy theory
It appears that the change in strategy was prompted by the anticipation that Maxwell's testimony could deal significant, perhaps irreparable, damage to Paxton's defense, a perspective shared by observers like Loewy and Cofer.
In keeping with their pattern, the Texas Scorecard Axis of Allies seems to be privately acknowledging the possibility of Paxton's conviction and removal from office. Consequently, they are now laying the groundwork for a conspiracy theory that they can promote within their echo chamber as the trial progresses into its second week:
"Theory: George P. Bush, TLR, the FBI, and Senators who voted to convict Paxton were colluding with the Texas House to oust Ken Paxton. This was not due to his alleged corruption as a public official but because he was investigating an undefined and highly provocative issue. This alleged conspiracy is believed to be the reason behind Deputy AGs signing letters on official letterhead without Ken Paxton's name on them."
Little said he is about to ask questions on the "mystery of the altered letterhead." #txlege @TheTexanNews
— Hayden Sparks (@HaydenJSparks) September 8, 2023
The removal of @KenPaxtonTX 's name from Office of the Attorney General letterhead seems like a minor petty thing, but it's actually indicative of high contempt by some in the office.
— Cary Cheshire (@CaryCheshireTX) September 6, 2023
Like him or not, Paxton was the duly elected AG. You serve at his pleasure or resign. #txlege
Ever heard the phrase "There are no coincidences in Austin"?
The correct response given by every witness for the prosecution in response to Paxton's defense attorneys is "No," as the phrase "There are no coincidences in Austin" is not a genuine saying or recognized expression.
Apparently the witnesses aren’t the only ones who haven’t heard of the phrase “there are no coincidences in Austin.” #txlege #PaxtonTrial pic.twitter.com/M0HiMveoBn
— Lauren McGaughy 🌟 (@lmcgaughy) September 8, 2023
It appears that Paxton's defense team is using the phrase "There are no coincidences in Austin" repeatedly, even though it lacks a basis as a common saying, as part of their strategy. This tactic aligns with the approach observed in how the Texas Scorecard's Axis of Allies influences public perception by reiterating claims, irrespective of their veracity, with the aim of ultimately shaping an alternate reality that garners belief among the public.
Once the transcripts from this trial are uploaded, this search result will change. #txlege pic.twitter.com/f6uDjSOaYM
— Brad Johnson (@bradj_TX) September 8, 2023
It's important to acknowledge that this approach has indeed found success in some instances. Certain individuals associated with The Enterprise, such as those suspected of being involved in promoting the QAnon conspiracy theory, have managed to gain a significant following and influence over a portion of the American population.
Also, remember the moment when Representative Tony Tinderholt inadvertently revealed how The Enterprise engage in deceptive practices?
I believe perception is truth to the person who perceives it. So, if someone perceives something, it's true to them, whether it's truth or not."
- Representative Tony Tinderholt
The Branch Davidian Connection
Ken Paxton's defense attorney, Dan Cogdell, played a significant role in the legal defense of Clive Doyle, a member of the Branch Davidians who faced charges related to the murder of federal agents.
Cogdell's legal team achieved a remarkable victory with a not guilty verdict for Clive Doyle after a grueling trial. This outcome was seen as a major triumph, not only for Doyle but also for Cogdell and his dedicated legal team, who had invested their all in defending their client.
On the investigative front, Ranger David Maxwell, a prominent figure among the Texas Rangers, played a crucial role in the initial Branch Davidian investigation.
The Branch Davidians, also known as the General Association of Branch Davidian Seventh-day Adventists, emerged as a splinter group from the Seventh-day Adventists.
The Assembly of Yahweh, also known as the Assembly of Yahweh 7th day, Farris Wilks' church, is another group with roots in the Seventh-day Adventists.
Coincidentally, the Wilks, Assembly of Yahweh, and the Branch Davidian compounds have buildings at the entrances, incredibly long driveways masking each compound with trees and green-space, making them challenging to observe from nearby roads. Each location appears uniquely similar to the others.
The Branch Davidian compound in Waco, Texas, was subjected to a federal raid in 1993.
On the 30th anniversary of the Waco siege, Donald Trump held a rally in Waco, Texas.
The current leader of the Branch Davidian community expressed that Donald Trump holding a rally in Waco, Texas on that particular weekend was significant. He believed that the former president was making a statement by visiting the same location where the government and the FBI had laid siege to their community.
I just spoke to a longtime Branch Davidian minister about the significance of Trump’s rally in Waco, during the 30-year anniversary of the standoff. He said Trump is clearly signaling.
— Robert Downen (@RobertDownen_) March 25, 2023
“He’s making a statement,” said the man, who was close with David Koresh. pic.twitter.com/5aBW3HAP4l
Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick, who has received $3,000,000 in contributions from The Enterprise, with financiers linked to the Seventh-day Adventist/Branch Davidian tradition, claimed credit for suggesting that Trump hold the rally in Waco on the anniversary of the Branch Davidian raid.
Notably, David Koresh, the leader of the Branch Davidians, was known for his paranoia regarding the FBI and had stockpiled heavy artillery in anticipation of a "prophecy" that the FBI would eventually come for their cult's compound.
The parallels between David Koresh and Donald Trump are indeed a cause for concern. As noted in a Texas Monthly article, the choice of Waco for Trump's first 2024 campaign rally carries a significant symbolism. The leader of the Branch Davidians drew a connection between Trump's visit and the government/FBI siege on their community, drawing illogical parallels to Mar-a-Lago. This comparison is further supported by the paranoid, conspiratorial, and anti-government rhetoric that resurfaced in Trump's and other speakers' speeches during the event, reminiscent of fringe sentiments from the 1990s.
The Enterprise Echoes Familiar Themes of the Branch Davidian
It's notable and concerning that almost identical paranoid, conspiratorial, and anti-government rhetoric appears within the messaging of Texas Scorecard's Axis of Allies.
Imagine calling yourself a conservative and saying you trust the FBI. #txlege
— Cary Cheshire (@CaryCheshireTX) September 7, 2023
The 4th witness in the @KenPaxtonTX impeachment trial, David Maxwell, admitted Paxton openly said he did not trust the FBI.
— Sara Gonzales (@SaraGonzalesTX) September 9, 2023
Maxwell said he believes in the FBI 𝑺𝑶 𝑴𝑼𝑪𝑯 that he said he thinks even 𝑰𝑵𝑽𝑬𝑺𝑻𝑰𝑮𝑨𝑻𝑰𝑵𝑮 the FBI is a 𝑪𝑹𝑰𝑴𝑬!
Do you agree? #txlege… pic.twitter.com/p0mPgAdF5t
Maxwell was definitely the prosecution’s best witness so far (a low bar). But the testimony was underwhelming. Accepting the premise that investigating the propriety of an FBI investigation is a crime is terrible precedent considering everything that’s happened recently.
— Matt Rinaldi (@MattRinaldiTX) September 8, 2023
Recent Developments After Our Initial Reports
Influenceable Hires Texas Monthly Reporter To Tweet Praise of Ken Paxton
A few weeks ago, Scorecard Confession brought to light the existence of a deceptive agency known as Influencable. This agency's purpose was to bypass Twitter's advertising platform and federal and state campaign finance laws. It was also revealed that Influenceable had questionable connections to Russian operatives who were associated with one of The Enterprise's financiers.
A @TexasMonthly writer signed up to see if he could get paid for tweeting about impeached Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton.
— Lauren McGaughy 🌟 (@lmcgaughy) September 8, 2023
He earned $100. Pure gold from @russellgold.https://t.co/KlSr36yp9P #txlege #PaxonTrial
In a recent development, a Texas Monthly reporter decided to test Influencable to see if they could get paid to promote Ken Paxton. Their experiment proved successful as they received a payment of $100. The payment came from an account associated with Brad Parscale's wife, Candice Parscale. Brad Parscale is the former head of digital operations for Donald Trump's 2016 campaign.
And I bet no one paid Congressman @chiproytx $50 for that tweet. https://t.co/N9phv27iZs
— Rep. Jared Patterson (@JaredLPatterson) September 8, 2023
They’re so desperate for people to care about the Paxton trial they literally paid The Texas Monthly $100 to tweet about it. The entire thing is astroturfed. pic.twitter.com/UsUZ2Gg8Ku
— Current Revolt (Tony O.) (@CurrentRevolt) September 8, 2023
All the replies are thirsty dudes.
— Current Revolt (Tony O.) (@CurrentRevolt) September 8, 2023
David Maxwell could’ve literally said anything today and the $50 fake activists would have made sure he was lied about and demeaned.
— Jason Vaughn (@JasonVaughn) September 9, 2023
Tim Dunn Is Tied to Nate Paul, Chinese Communist Party
Scorecard Confessions has previously published reports on the Wilks brothers' connections with the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). Now, The Texas Voice has revealed ties between another financier of The Enterprise, Tim Dunn, and both the CCP and Nate Paul.
Cameron is listed as a Director of Pipeline Media, Inc., an Illinois-based business entity, alongside Midland businessman and prominent political donor Tim Dunn. Cameron and Dunn were named as Defendants in a 2021 lawsuit brought in Federal Court in Missouri that alleged Cameron and Dunn were part of a scheme to fraudulently transfer assets from a business entity at the Plaintiff’s alleged detriment. The lawsuit was dismissed in favor of Cameron and Dunn.
Situation Management Group also maintains an office in Beijing, and Cameron and his company advertise close ties to the Chinese government. Cameron’s biography on the Situation Management Group website describes him as “the only US representative of the Kangda Law Firm in China, which serves as the Chinese government’s official liaison to Western companies.”
Scorecard Confessions mentioned in The Washington Post
This week, the Post reported that Ken Paxton had allegedly skipped his impeachment trial to receive a message at the Omni Barton Creek Resort, information obtained from reliable sources initially by Scorecard Confessions. Additionally, a reporter from The Washington Post reiterated an intriguing detail that had emerged concerning Paxton's extramarital affair:
Of note: Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s personal aide told House investigators that he saw the attorney general and his alleged mistress at the Omni Barton Creek in 2020, where Paxton was staying as his Austin home was remodeled — allegedly on donor Nate Paul’s dime. https://t.co/KbdyTKAWrT
— Molly Hennessy-Fiske (@mollyhf) September 7, 2023